I've read this entire series. The early books were quite good (at least in my memory) but the last few have become overly cutesy, stuck in the same repetitive motifs, and verging on silly. This is the worst of the lot with surface characterizations and overly convoluted hackneyed plot lines. Any character descriptions and insights are repeated and repeated and repeated.......I begin to suspect Penny has a Three Pines program and just slots in new sentences here and there. I doubt I will read another.